The Best Local Bakeries for Thanksgiving Desserts
Open house this Saturday at 10am-12pm - 1906 Grouse Court Forks Twp, PA RSVP
Apple, pumpkin, and lattice-topped Thanksgiving pies on metal stands on a dark bakery table, warm light and a wisp of steam over the golden crusts
Holiday November 19, 2026

The Best Local Bakeries for Thanksgiving Desserts

Share this article
Apple, pumpkin, and lattice-topped Thanksgiving pies on metal stands on a dark bakery table, warm light and a wisp of steam over the golden crusts
Tim Tepes headshot
Tim Tepes
PA Licensed Associate Broker and REALTOR® · Better Homes and Gardens® Real Estate Cassidon Realty
Published:

The pie is the most important decision on the Thanksgiving table, and this year the Lehigh Valley's bakeries have it handled. These local bakeries take holiday pre-orders, so the dessert is taken care of and your oven stays free for the turkey. Thanksgiving 2026 is Thursday, November 26.

Below is a genuine local guide: five Lehigh Valley bakeries taking Thanksgiving dessert orders, two more worth calling, and answers to the questions people ask most this time of year. Pre-order windows vary from bakery to bakery, so the smart play is to call early.

Prices, hours, and pre-order deadlines change quickly around the holidays. Everything below was compiled from business websites and public listings in mid-November 2026. Call ahead to confirm your order before you make the trip.

5 local bakeries for Thanksgiving desserts

These five bakeries are taking Thanksgiving dessert orders in the Lehigh Valley. Call each one to confirm this year's pre-order window and pickup timing.

Vallo's Bakery

Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

A family bakery serving the Valley since 1926, Vallo's is known for donuts, all-occasion cakes, cupcakes, pies, pastries, biscotti, sticky buns, breads, and rolls. It also runs a stand at the Allentown Farmers Market.

Pre-order Thanksgiving pies and treats by calling the store.

Hours are Tuesday through Saturday 8:00 AM to 4:00 PM and Sunday 8:00 AM to noon; closed Monday.

Check the website

Pie + Tart

349 Northampton St., downtown Easton, a few doors from the Easton Public Market

A small-batch urban bakery specializing in pies and tarts, sweet and savory. Pie + Tart takes Thanksgiving pre-orders with pickup scheduled in the days before the holiday.

Order early, because small-batch pies sell out.

Call or stop in to place a 2026 order.

Check the website

Easton Baking Company

Near downtown Easton, Pennsylvania

A traditional American bakery established in 1922, described on its own site as the oldest bakery still operating in the Lehigh Valley. It bakes classic pies from scratch using time-honored recipes, along with its iconic Lehigh Valley tomato pie, breads, rolls, donuts, cakes, cookies, and pastry.

Place Thanksgiving or special-occasion orders by phone or through the contact form on its website.

Check the website

Vegan Treats

1444 Linden St., Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

A vegan bakery known for completely plant-based desserts. Vegan Treats offers a 9-inch gluten-free pumpkin pie and a full holiday lineup of treats.

Many holiday items are pre-order only, so call ahead to reserve a Thanksgiving pie and confirm pickup timing.

(610) 861-7660

Check the website

Bakery by Perkins

3940 Nazareth Pike, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania

A full-service bakery open daily from 6:00 AM to 10:00 PM. Its whole pies include homestyle apple, chocolate French silk, banana cream, wildberry, and caramel apple.

Whole-pie orders are limited to 3 per flavor so more customers can get one. Call the location for holiday quantities or pre-orders.

Check the website

Two more worth a call

  • Back Door Bakeshop in Bethlehem is a coffee shop and bakery whose homemade Thanksgiving pies have earned customer raves. Call to ask about holiday pre-orders. Check the website.
  • From Scratch Baking Company is a scratch bakery taking Thanksgiving pie orders with gluten-free options. Pies run from around $30, and its published last order date is Thursday, November 19, 2026. Confirm the pickup location and hours directly with the bakery.

Thanksgiving dessert questions, answered

Where can I pre-order a Thanksgiving pie in the Lehigh Valley?

Vallo's in Bethlehem, Pie + Tart and Easton Baking Company in Easton, Vegan Treats in Bethlehem, and Bakery by Perkins on Nazareth Pike all take Thanksgiving dessert orders. Call each bakery for this year's pre-order window.

Do any local bakeries make gluten-free or vegan Thanksgiving desserts?

Vegan Treats in Bethlehem offers a 9-inch gluten-free pumpkin pie and is fully vegan. Other bakeries can confirm dietary options by phone, and From Scratch Baking Company lists gluten-free pie options too. Call ahead if you need a gluten-free or vegan dessert.

How much does a Thanksgiving pie cost?

Prices vary by bakery and size, from whole pies around $16 at Bakery by Perkins to roughly $30 and up at small-batch scratch bakeries. Call for exact pricing before you order.

When should I order to be safe?

Many bakeries close their holiday pre-orders one to seven days before Thanksgiving, with pickup on Wednesday, November 25. Order as early as possible, and confirm the pickup window with the bakery.

Can I buy a pie the day before Thanksgiving?

Bakery by Perkins sells whole pies daily, including same-day pickup, with a limit of 3 per flavor. Most small bakeries require pre-orders, so call ahead the day before to see what is available.

Pie's handled. Now about your move.

Ask Tim Tepes what the Lehigh Valley market looks like this season.

Tim Tepes Real Estate, a member of Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate Cassidon Realty Better Homes and Gardens Real Estate
Tim Tepes
PA Licensed Associate Broker · AB062628L

Enjoy the holiday, and when the leftovers are gone, if you are thinking about a move in the Lehigh Valley, call Tim at (484) 275-0056, or send Tim a message online.

Holiday Thanksgiving Dining Guide Lehigh Valley
Tim Tepes, PA Licensed Associate Broker
Tim Tepes
PA Licensed Associate Broker · AB062628L

With more than 36 years of real estate experience and over 2,000 home sales since 1990, Tim Tepes is a trusted expert in Lehigh Valley real estate. He is the founder of Tim Tepes Real Estate LLC with Better Homes and Gardens® Real Estate Cassidon Realty.

Ask Tim about the Lehigh Valley market →
Share this article

Pie's handled. Now about your move.

Ask Tim Tepes what the Lehigh Valley market looks like this season. Whether you are buying, selling, or just curious about your home's value, Tim can walk you through the current numbers.

Tim Tepes · PA Licensed Associate Broker & Realtor®

Ready to make your next move?

Get an honest, no-pressure estimate of what your home is worth, or book a free 30-minute goals call to plan your next step in the Lehigh Valley.

Prefer to talk it through? Tim is one call away at (484) 275-0056.

Free Investor Resource

Explore the Investment Properties Guide

Cap Rates, 1031 Exchanges, DSTs & More, Everything You Need to Know About Building Wealth Through Real Estate Investing.

Compiled by Tim Tepes, Pennsylvania Licensed Associate Broker | REALTOR® with Over 36 Years of Real Estate Experience helping investors succeed in the Lehigh Valley and beyond.

Get the Free Investment Guide

Explore Our Featured Communities

Home Value Text Tim Goals Call